| Home Contents |
1.2
-- THE SHADOW LAND |
|
ECCLESIASTES
1.2 Vanity of vanities, says the Koheleth; Vanity of vanities -- All [the whole] is Vanity [Empty, Futile, Transitory, Boring, Unsatisfactory, like a Vapour or mist, Smoke, a Shadow]. |
||
Although Solomon himself, as the Koheleth, was the epitome of the successful man, massively wealthy, extremely wise, capable and creative, and a magnet to the most beautiful of women, God led him to see that his life was Vain – from a Hebrew word capable of conveying a range of meanings, such as utterly Futile, Empty, Boring and Unsatisfactory, a waste of time, as transient as a morning mist, a puff of smoke, a mere shadow of the real thing. The threefold repetition of the word Vanity in this single verse stresses the certainty of his sobering assertion. The modern translator Knox may be close one of Solomon’s inspired intentions in this particular verse when he renders it, Quote: "A shadow of a shadow, a shadow of a shadow, the whole is a shadow" -- an outlook shared by the Greek philosopher Plato, who lived several centuries after Solomon, and who taught that the material objects we embrace in this world no more represents ultimate reality itself than the shadows cast by the sun on the rear wall of a deep cave represent the objects moving across its entrance. Perhaps Solomon is saying that we do in fact inhabit such a "cave" -- with the result that our perceptions of reality are just as crude, distorted and lacking in meaningful detail as the shadows cast by the sun. Although Solomon was denied a full knowledge of God’s plan for mankind (1 Peter 1:10-12), he could apparently sense that there was more to this human existence than the apparent futility and disappointment that he and so many others experienced. Plato
may indeed have owed a debt to Solomon and those taught by him, and some
early Christian scholars believed that even classic Greek architecture
was inspired by Solomon's temple, and also that much of their science
and philosophy may have been brought to them by learned Jews who were
scattered abroad when Solomon's empire was destroyed after his death.
Perhaps the same might be true of other schools of Greek philosophy such
as the Hedonists, whose teachings seem to have elements in common with
those found in Ecclesiastes. The apostle James, a keen student of wisdom, seems to be referring back to this same verse of Ecclesiastes when he urges some Christian businessmen who were becoming consumed by selfish ambition to get a better perspective on life, saying, Quote: "Why, you do not even know what will happen tomorrow. What is your life? You are a mist that appears for a little while and then vanishes" (James 4:14). The apostle Paul also appears to be citing this same verse when he says of our very imperfect understanding of reality that, Quote: "Now we see through a glass darkly" (1 Corinthians 13:12). In translating Paul’s mysterious phrase, Greek scholars offer a variety of possibilities, such as -- a poor reflection in a mirror, in a mirror darkly, a mirror in darkness, a blurred reflection of reality, through a dim window, squinting in a fog, and peering through a mist. Perhaps
Paul was inspired to extend Solomon's metaphor when he compared our incomplete
perception of reality to the reflection of light in an imperfect mirror
or any shiny but warped surface for that matter -- a magical process that
laterally inverts reality, so that, if looking in a mirror to trim a hair,
for example, we tend to move our hand to the right when we should move
to the left, and vice versa. Is it significant that human nature has a
similar effect on our actions? -- so that we often find ourselves inclined
to do the precise opposite of what we should do, to the extent that even
mass murderers apparently rationalize that they are actually doing good
and right when they kill their victims. Perhaps Solomon was, in fact, somewhat like a highly precocious child who looks at his toys and suddenly sees them for what they are – bits of wood, metal and plastic, mere playthings. As a result, he saw that all the success he had toiled and striven to attain in this transient existence was ultimately futile, because, like all men, he would die and leave it behind. Perhaps Paul has such matters in mind when, in the verse following the one just cited, he urges Christians to grow up spiritually and get real, saying, Quote: “When I was a child, I though like a child. But I became a man, I put away childish things” (1 Corinthians 13:11). |
||