Contents
6 -- THE SIN OF THE FALSE LEADERS
 
 

VERSES 8-10: In the very same way these filthy dreamers also pollute the flesh, despise authority, and defame dignities.

Yet Michael the archangel, when contending with the devil he disputed about the body of Moses, dared not bring against him a railing accusation, but said, The Lord rebuke you.

But these speak abusively against those things which they do not understand: but what they know naturally, as brute beasts, in those things they corrupt themselves.

 
Contents

Jude now moves on to describe the pseudo-Christian leaders who were turning the grace of God into a license for immorality in general and the practice of homosexuality in particular.

Jude now homes in on the specific sins of the pseudo-Christian leaders, saying that their immoral practices were the very same as those of Sodom and Gomorrah -- in other words, sexual immorality in general, and homosexuality in particular.

Filthy Dreamers Pollute their Flesh

The practice of homosexuality pollutes the flesh, both figuratively and literally, which is why Jude refers to the false leaders, who may well have claimed to receive special new revelations in dreams, as filthy dreamers.

They Despise Authority

Notice that the false teachers also reject or despise authority or dominion. Nobody is going to tell them how to live their lives. They will set their own moral standards, as we have already seen, and not even the plain authority of the Bible is acceptable to them.Peter describes them as being bold and arrogant in their manner (2 Peter 2:10).

They Defame Dignities

Jude tells us that the false teachers were not afraid to defame dignities, leaders -- and were no doubt skilled in the subtle techniques of character assassination.In the same way, today’s pseudo-Christian teachers are not afraid to accuse the apostle Paul of being homophobic and biased against women, a naïve victim of the culture he lived in. As Paul points out (1 Corinthians 1:26-28), God generally call out weak and foolish individuals, and sometimes the downright odd, to do His work -- and even the original apostles were not highly educated, cultured, wealthy and successful men. They also had their fair share of human weaknesses, as the scriptures make clear, and no doubt made many mistakes. Peter, for example, had problems accepting the fact that the Gentiles could be saved, and had to be rebuked by Paul on one occasion for his conduct (Galatians 2:11). Paul himself admits that he was unimpressive as a speaker and lacking in presence as leader (2 Corinthians 10:10; 11:6). Perhaps, as a result of these things, it was relatively easy for certain charismatic and capable men to worm their way into the Church, perhaps even having held priestly office in Judaism, and acquire positions of influence – positions from which they were later able to criticize and distort the teachings of Paul, as we have already seen, and introduce permissive doctrines, possibly based on supposed new revelations and dreams.

Things They Do not Understand

In spiritual matters, which they do not understand, says Jude, the false teachers are like brute beasts -- meaning stupid or unreasoning animals. Just as many animals can hear and see and taste, touch and smell even better than human beings but have little or no power of reason, so the false teachers may be able to reason very cleverly as human beings but have no grasp of spiritual matters – which is why an erudite scholar, even with an ability to read the original Greek and Hebrew texts from which our Bible is translated, may possess very little understanding of the ways of God, and possess even less desire to follow them.As a result, instead of striving to live holy lives that fulfill the spirit of the law of God, as Jesus taught his disciples, the false teachers regard the Bible as a legal document in which they hope to find loopholes and omissions to excuse their personal immoral actions.

Homosexual Offenders

We saw earlier, for example, Paul’s list of those will excluded from eternal life in the Kingdom of God -- the sexually immoral, idolaters, adulterers, male prostitutes, homosexual offenders, thieves, the greedy, drunkards, slanderers and swindlers.Although nobody leaps to the defense of practicing thieves, drunkards, liars and the like, today’s generation of the false teachers, to whom Jude’s comments also apply, do take particular issue with the phrase "homosexual offenders" -- pointing out that the meaning of the original Greek word, arsenokoites, is somewhat obscure. Nevertheless, the term, which is a combination of the Greek words for male and bed, has been translated by well informed scholars in a variety of similar ways -- including: "abusers of themselves with mankind", "men who are guilty of sexual intercourse with members of their own sex", "those guilty of homosexual perversion", or simply "homosexuals" or "sodomites". However, even if the term does mean homosexual, claim the false leaders, it is referring to the practice as part of pagan temple worship -- a totally different thing to the loving, caring kind of homosexuality to that they claim to promote.

Bibliolatry

As for the Old Testament, and the clear condemnation of homosexuality we have already seen in both Genesis and Leviticus, the false teachers simply claim that as Christians those scriptures no longer apply to them -- and were, in any case, misconstrued by New Testament writers such as Paul and Jude, leading to erroreous comments on the subject in the New Testament.Astonishingly, some of them go so far as to suggest that anybody who does look to the Bible, either Old or New Testament, as a guide to Christian living is guilty of "bibliolatry" -- the sin of idolizing and worshipping the Bible!

Interpretive Theory

Going one step further than that, however, theologians have now devised the "interpretive theory" -- the notion that Christians, being led by the Spirit of God and their own intuition and personal revelations, should actually critique the Holy Scriptures rather than regard them as a holy writ, accepting the bits they like and discarding the rest. After all, they claim, although the men who wrote the Bible in the first place may have worshipped God, they were not only superstitious, scientifically illiterate and lacking the benefit of a modern textual scholarship, but also prejudiced against homosexuals and women to boot because of the culture in which they lived -- so we know better! Finally, in the newspaper this very morning we find their ultimate pronouncement -- namely that belief in the Bible is in fact "a complete irrelevance" for Christians.

All Scripture is Inspired

Although the pseudo-Christian leaders happily reject the whole of the Old Testament, the apostle Paul exhorted the evangelist Timothy to study the Hebrew scriptures very carefully, saying: "All scripture is inspired by God and is profitable for teaching, rebuking, correcting and training in righteousness" (2 Timothy 3:16). In the previous letter to Timothy, however, Paul describes a different group of false teachers who attacked from the exact opposite direction -- wanting to impose the detailed requirements of the Old Covenant on Christians. Of such he says, in words echoed by Jude: "They want to be teachers of the law, but they do not know what they are talking about or what they so confidently affirm" (1 Timothy 1:7).

The Value of the Law

Paul then makes a comment that applies equally to both groups, saying: "We know that the law is good -- if one uses it lawfully. We also know that the law is made not for the righteous man but for law breakers" (verse 8). Although the Christian is not required to live by the Law, by being circumcised, for example, observing the seventh day Sabbath made holy at Creation, paying tithes in the way Abraham did, celebrating the Holy Days of the Hebrew Calendar, or obeying all the statutes and ritual cleansings imposed by the Law of Moses, all those requirements were based on right principles. As Paul explains, for example, circumcision, which involved the removal of a tiny portion of flesh, was an outward symbol of the true circumcision in the heart, a turning away from the lusts of the flesh, and is no longer required (Galatians 5:6).

The Sabbath and Tithing

Also, although Christians are not required to tithe their income or save a second tithe, as Moses commanded to finance the celebration of the annual festivals, or even a third tithe to distribute to the poor and orphans, they should willingly use their income to honour God and help those in need. With regard to the Sabbath, a Christian, led by the indwelling of the Holy Spirit, is supposed to make every day of the week holy by his conduct, by resting from sin. The unwilling Israelites, however, under the Old Covenant, required a special day to be imposed in order to make them stop working and to take time to worship God.

The Law was a Schoolmaster

This is why Paul explains to Greek Christians in Galatia, on whom a different group of false teachers had tried to impose circumcision and also the annual holy days, such as the Passover and the Days of Unleavened Bread, that: "The law was our schoolmaster, to bring us unto Christ" (Galations 3:24). In other words, the law taught right principles in the form of detailed rules and regulations, as any good parent does with their young and often unwilling children.Although other parts of the Law, such as various kinds of sacrifices and purification rituals, cannot be literally followed at the present time because there is no temple, Paul says that the Christian is still required to purify his heart and offer himself spiritually as a living sacrifice to do God’s will (Romans 12:1).

Important Principles

Likewise, the many and detailed statutes such as those pertaining to building a parapet around a flat root (safety), not eating blood or unclean animals (health), not using mixed fabrics (quality), quarantining people with various diseases (public health), burying excrement (hygiene), not yoking an ox with a donkey (kindness to animals), not reaping the corners of fields (kindness to the poor), all taught important principles, some of which science has only discovered in recent centuries.Further, although the ministration of death, by which the Law imposed the death penalty for a variety of offenses, including adultery, homosexuality and bestiality, for example, is no longer physically in force (2 Corinthians 3:6-7), those acts are still immoral and sinful and carry an ultimate penalty of death that will be imposed by God on those who indulge in them -- a major stumbling block to the pseudo-Christian leaders today as in the time of Jude.

Religionless Religion

In summary, the Christian is called to live a righteous life -- one that is totally free of specific rules, regulations and rituals on the one hand, but that is also free from the immoral acts of the flesh on the other. This is why Christianity has been called a religion-less religion.However, some people find this responsible freedom difficult to accept, now as in the first century -- many wanting the reassurance of a set of rigid rules and rituals to live by, with many others wanting the unconstrained license to indulge themselves as they sit fit.This is what Paul tries to explain to Christians living in Galatia, Quote: "You, my brothers, were called to be free -- but do not use your freedom to indulge the sinful nature" (Galatians 5:13). He then goes on to list the sins of the flesh that are to be resisted, as we have already seen (verses 19-21), and the fruits of the Holy Spirit that should replace them (verses 22-24).Paul also explains this same principle to converts to Christianity in the sexual cess pit of Corinth, saying, after discussing several problems, Quote: "Everything is permissible for me -- but not everything is beneficial. Everything is permissible -- but I will not be mastered by anything" (1 Corinthians 6:12). Having made this sweeping statement, Paul immediately qualifies it by pointing out that he is, of course, as a disciple of Christ, speaking of everything that is not immoral, and sexually immoral in particular (verses 13 and 18). He then stresses once again the need for Christians to live holy lives, their bodies being temples of the Holy Spirit (verse19).